Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Carl's avatar

Dr Syrigos,

I would like to applaud your explanation of the religious and Jungian insights you mention in the human perception of evil. However I believe that you have fallen into and perpetuate the mistaken notion of "human exceptionalism".

Each of the examples of "evil" and "the demons" that humanity wrestles with are humanities own constructs. With time encompassing varying perspectives and interpretations, there is no difference between good (for whom) and evil (to whom), except perspective. Human perspective specifically.

As integral and natural expressions of Earth's evolutionary history, humans and human reactions are as natural and benign as any other phenomenon that happens in or on our world. That immediately questions whether humanity, exclusively according to some religions has an otherworldly "spiritual" component. Many wish we do, I think not.

Does one Ant colony attacking another an evil act? Does one Deer eating better browse, denying another an evil act? Does one human tribe pursuing resources more than their immediate need create a dichotomy of good and evil?

Our perspective needs adjusting. Good-evil is a spectrum disorder like intelligence (first clarify the definition of intelligent) not, except through a very narrow perspective, opposing attributes. I'd assert that the missing and necessary quality is equilibrium as demonstrated in virtually any natural process. Given time, equilibrium or harmony as professed by the Budda accounts for deficient human perspective.

We make this stuff up. Define ourselves by our limited insight and ascribe similar attributes to what we actually do and don't understand. Again, we understand little which is why we create fantastical story lines to explain our selves to ourselves.

Good and evil are not a battleground they are precepts of our own behaviors intermingled by perspective. Ethically everything has the same fundamental "right" to exist, until doesn't. Humanity creates the comparison and creates concepts of good or evil. It recognizes equilibrium/harmony as the sea-saw of existence.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts